I still remember the exact moment—October 2023, three years ago now in 2026—when my V stood in that abandoned metro station, the weight of the Relic ticking like a countdown to oblivion in my skull. My hands were sweating on the controller, my eyes darting between Songbird’s desperate Avian silhouette and Reed’s grim, duty-bound expression. You know that feeling when a game isn’t just a game anymore? When it’s more terrifying than a real-life ultimatum? That’s Firestarter. And let me tell you, Cyberpunk 2077: Phantom Liberty doesn’t just break your heart—it rips it out, rewires it with illegal chrome, and asks you to choose which piece of yourself you’re willing to lose forever.

phantom-liberty-s-firestarter-quest-a-choice-so-brutal-it-nearly-fried-my-brain-image-0

Player choice in an open-world RPG—it’s the golden promise, right? And Cyberpunk 2077 delivers that promise with a sledgehammer. The original game gave us endings that revolved around V and that cursed Relic biochip, but none of them offered the one thing I truly craved: getting the damn thing out of my head. Until Phantom Liberty! Three years ago, CD Projekt Red blessed (or cursed) us with a DLC expansion so narratively dense, so emotionally manipulative, that I still wake up in cold sweats thinking about the moment I had to pick between Song So Mi (Songbird) and Solomon Reed. Spoiler warning? Oh, honey—if you haven’t played it by 2026, you’re already living under a rock the size of Arasaka Tower.

So let’s set the stage. After getting tangled up with a ragtag squad of FIA agents—liars, betrayers, walking time bombs of personal baggage—V finds themselves in the Firestarter quest, surrounded by the kind of tension that makes the air feel like electrified concrete. Songbird had orchestrated a rendezvous to grab the AI neural matrix from Kurt Hansen’s stash. Everything was going according to plan... until the plan dissolved into a choice so catastrophic that my braincells began self-destructing like faulty cyberware. At the climax of that final extraction, V is forced to decide: help Songbird escape or assist Reed. I’m telling you, I sat there for a full twenty minutes, staring at the screen. Did I mention my heart rate was probably visible through my chest? Because it was.

phantom-liberty-s-firestarter-quest-a-choice-so-brutal-it-nearly-fried-my-brain-image-1

Now, let’s dissect this demonic decision tree, shall we? 🧠⚡

  • Side with Reed: This path doesn’t end quickly, oh no. It drags you through a brutal gauntlet of quests where you eventually face a choice—kill Songbird or spare her from the Blackwall’s hungry maw. Reed might live, and So Mi might even get a twisted form of rescue, but it’s a path soaked in moral ambiguity and the kind of betrayal that makes your stomach churn like a faulty cyberdeck.

  • Side with Songbird: This is the express elevator to mayhem. You either put a bullet through Reed’s skull (yes, you pull the trigger) or you give So Mi up. But crucially—crucially—sticking with Songbird unlocks the exclusive, game-changing ending that we all fantasized about since the DLC’s announcement: V gets the Relic removed. A true miracle! But the cost? Oh, you’d better believe there’s a cost. Your cyberware becomes useless. You can’t even walk without relearning how. Neural damage so severe it’s like your body is a prison made of flesh instead of chrome. A second chance at life, sure, but I have to ask: Is it worth it? Is any ending in this dystopian hellscape truly worth it?

phantom-liberty-s-firestarter-quest-a-choice-so-brutal-it-nearly-fried-my-brain-image-2

I’ve seen forums burn down over which ending is the “good” one. Truthfully? The beauty—and the agony—of Phantom Liberty is that there is no good ending. Reed’s path might save both him and Songbird, but you know what that “salvation” feels like? A beautifully wrapped gift box containing a live grenade. And Songbird’s path? The one unlocking that shiny new ending? It leaves you broken, stripped of everything that made you a legend of Night City. I can’t even count how many times I’ve screamed at my monitor: “Is this what you wanted, CD Projekt Red? To turn us all into emotional wrecks?” 🤬

But you know what? That’s exactly what the Cyberpunk genre demands. No easy choices, no triumphant heroes riding into the sunset. President Myers isn’t safe, the FIA is a nest of vipers, and even the people you trust are lying through their teeth. When I side with Reed, I’m haunted by the look in Songbird’s eyes. When I side with Songbird, I hear Reed’s voice in my nightmares. And the exclusive ending? It forced me to watch V, my V—the merc who toppled giants—reduced to learning how to walk again, all while the world moved on without her. It’s a masterstroke of storytelling that, even in 2026, hasn’t lost an ounce of its gut-punch power.

Let’s talk numbers, because my brain is wired for stats: 🤖

Choice Path Outcome for Reed Outcome for Songbird V's Fate
Aid Reed Can be saved (living with the consequences) Can be killed or spared from Blackwall Original endings only (no cure)
Help Songbird Must be shot (or So Mi given up) Escapes or is captured Unlocks exclusive new ending – Relic removed, cyberware lost, neural damage

Look at that table! It’s a menu of misery, and every option comes with a side of existential despair. I’ve played Phantom Liberty multiple times since 2023, and each replay only deepens my respect—and my trauma. Even now, with all the mods and patches and community guides available, the Firestarter choice remains the single most defining moment of my gaming life. Did I make the right call? Does it even matter? I’ll never know, and that’s the point. The world of Cyberpunk 2077 is so profoundly gray that even the “miracle cure” ending tastes like ash on my tongue. But I wouldn’t have it any other way.

If you haven’t experienced this for yourself, what are you waiting for? Cyberpunk 2077: Phantom Liberty is available right now in 2026 for PC, PS5, and Xbox Series X/S. Go ahead—make your choice. I’ll be here, still trembling, remembering the moment I pulled that trigger on Reed... or was it Songbird? I can never remember anymore. And maybe that’s the most terrifying ending of all. 💀💔